Tuesday, 27 September 2011

Genres

Have you ever struggled to apply a genre to a book you are reviewing? I certainly have. Especially as I am quite new to this and trying to specify a single genre against a book is rather tricky.

Most recently I was trying to determine the genre of a book and was thinking about putting it down to biography or memoir but I realised I wasn't perfectly clear what a memoir really was so I did a little research.

Now to understand this first we need to define an auto-biography and a biography. That's relatively simple; the first is a book about a person written by that person and the second is a book about a person written by someone else. That's pretty clear.

However a memoir is a little trickier. A memoir for many is classed as a sub-genre of auto-biography in which the story focuses on an aspect of the person's life. It may be only one time in a person's life, or one event or simply one aspect of their life. A memoir focuses on the emotions, moods and attitudes within the story rather than the factual events that occurred.

So the question I have is can a memoir be a biography? According to the literal definition of the genre, no. But why not? Take for example the book I mentioned earlier; tuesdays with Morrie. This book centers around the death of Morrie Schwatz, his feelings and thoughts and emotions about dying. If it had been written by himself I would have no qualms about saying this was a memoir. But it wasn't written by Morrie Schwatz, it was written by Mitch Albom. But here's the clincher the book is also about Albom and his experiences with Morrie. So is this book actually a memoir about Albom or a biography of Schwatz?

On a side note I fight with the genre Literary Fiction. Is it really a genre? Or is it just a term to try and differentiate a 'serious' book from it's counterparts? If we define a book on our blog to be literary fiction should was also assign it another genre to help clairfy it?

I am fascinated by genres (especially when a book doesn't fit into one) and find it a great way to fuel a discussion. So what do you think? Have you read the book and have an opinion on it's genre? Do you think a biography can be a memoir? Is there another genre I haven't heard of that could define a biographical memoir? What do you think of Literary Fiction as a genre? Do you even care about genres? Tell me your thoughts.

Comments (4)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
Good question! I rarely think much about genres, since most of the fiction I read falls into the vague category of literary fiction, but I do find it interesting with biographical writing. Some examples such as Helen Thomas' As It Was, and Christopher Milne's The Enchanted Places, are somewhat confusing because they're half-autobiography and half-biography - Thomas' is about herself and her husband; Milne's about himself and his father. Where should the line be drawn?!
1 reply · active 716 weeks ago
Ah now there's a good question. Can a book be an auto-biography and a biography at the same time? Interesting. p.s. like the look of The Enchanted Places, just added it to my goodreads list :)
I ponder about these things all the time. I suppose the thing is that books can be different kinsd of genres at once, and that can be confusing. A book can be literary fictiona nd crime fiction at the same time, or science fiction and a classic. Sometimes its even harder to classify. Have you read The Passage by Justin Cronin? That could be so many different genres I don't even know where to start.

But I do like it when a book is more than one genre - it means that there are more ways to think about it.

The only time it ever really caused an issue for me that I can think of was with Jasper Jones by Craig Silvey, an Australian book. I read it thinking it was a piece of contemporary Australian literature, but it read like YA which threw me a bit.
1 reply · active 715 weeks ago
I haven't read The Passage but had a quick peak on goodreads and I can see what you mean. There it's listed under Horror, Paranormal, Fantasy, Science Fiction, Post Apocolyptic, Thriller and Dystopian. Wow!
I do like books that don't fit into a normal classification too but I think it does make it tricker when writing blog reviews :)

Post a new comment

Comments by